Cary Pinkowski did the Heroic Thing--My letter to CNN on the LSB Chicago Marathon


Sunday night, CNN spends their time speaking about the humid conditions at the race. Then, on Monday, it is Chaos in Chicago. By Tuesday, runners, are hanging Pinkowski in effigy. Here is the letter I posted to CNN on Tuesday night about what really happened at the race....

As the publisher of American Track & Field and president of the Running Network, a group of 34 regional and national running magazines, I have to tell you, Cary Pinkowski, the Race Director of La Salle Banks Chicago Marathon had two choices-let people get very sick, and perhaps more die, or take the courageous step and close the race down. 10,000 people did not even show up! The folks that ran, and I spoke to 100 of them after the race, were exhausted from the heat, and dissappointed from the tough conditions, but they should have been pleased that race management closed the race down! Why did water allegedly run out? Because many first timers, probably 2/3 of the field panicked and poured water on themselves and there was no way to plan for that!
Try and put yourself in Pinkowski' shoes-keep the race open, and be criticized for people dying and more getting hospitalized, or closing it down and getting criticized for ruining someone's day. It is only a race, and life is much more important. Pinkowski choose to keep 35,000 people from risking their lives.

Larry Eder
American Track & Field
Running Network, LLC

The LSB Chicago Marathon in 2007 will be remembered for several things-amazing finishes by the elite athletes and Cary Pinkowski having the backbone enough to cancel the race.

Cary Pinkowski is a running geek. This is a good thing. He and Mike Nishi, and their team, want to put on the best race that they can. For nearly seventeen years now, Pinkowski and company have worked to make the LSB Chicago Marathon one of the top races in the world. It is a global race. Add that to a resurging ING New York, BAA Boston, FLORA London, real,-Berlin, among others and you have the World Majors.

I remember, in 1997 or so, late in the evening watching Cary checking out the course, it was probably 2 am ( we were coming back from a party). I had seen the same look before on the late Fred Lebow's face, the heralded race director of the New York City Marathon, and resident eccentric at the New York Road Runners. Lebow INVENTED the city marathons. When he moved the New York race from five laps of Central Park to five boroughs in 1976, many thought he was smoking something illegal. I have spoken to a first sponsor, or who should have been, of New York-Lebow asked for $5k and they thought the Romanian apparel salesman was crazy.

Pinkowski comes from a running pedigree. In the 1970's 75-76, he went to high school with Rudy Chapa, Mike Keogh and Cary P, they were all under nine minutes for two miles! In Indiana, and Gary, Indiana of all places. Cary was an amazing running in high school, ran well in college and ran a 2;22 marathon after that.

His love the marathon and his absolutely anal attachment to managing races is why he is so good! The attention to details, putting out more water, sports drinks, ice, air conditioned vehicles, water misters on Saturday showed that. That the weather, 87 degrees and 86 degree humidty, did them in, only shows that Mother Nature still has some control over man.

The responsibility of the lives or deaths of 45,000 marathoners is something I hope I never, ever, ever have to consider. That Pinkowski could make the decision should be applauded. But to second guess him is just plain juvenile. Disagree, but respect the man for showing the guts, unlike most politicians today, to make a decision and stick with it.

I have had disagreements with Cary before, and he welcomes that. A pretty open guy for someone in such a position of authority, Cary PInkowski saved the LSB Chicago Marathon-or whatever Bank of America is going to call it. By closing the race, he saved the day from being really tough, to being a war zone.

For the whole picture on the La Salle Bank Chicago Marathon, please
check the coverage from the Running Network:

3 Comments | Leave a comment

I wanted to thank Greg Meyer and the first respondent. I do not disagree with the first respondent, but I do believe that this goes under Act of God, or Bad, Very Bad, Karma Day.

Having run the race on Sunday, I have to agree with Larry that Carrie Pinkowski and the race officals did the right thing. While I was passing the water stops early enough to get water, I was also one of those drinking three cups and pouring two on my head.

While I know many people were disappointed, the race would have been canceled had a tornado warning occured, or another major weather event. My opinion is that race officals acted in the best interest of the runners, given the information they had. I commend them on a tough decision.

Runners must have been pouring Gatorade over their heads too - you know, to explain the complete lack of Gatorade on most of the course too!

And you talked to 100 runners? Wow! Is that statistically significant? 100 out of 36,000? Where were they in the pack? Front of the pack? Who were they? Friends of Carey Pinkowski?

Us runners are loyal and forgiving, trained to expect the unexpected. But Pinkowski needs to do the right thing and apologize. The marathon was a disaster and it was not because the faster runners were supposedly pouring water over their heads.

Finally, Larry, at least 50 people were in the gas station with me at LaSalle and Clark buying beverages at Mile 4. You might want to ask them if there was sufficient water and Gatorade on the course.

Leave a comment

Wake up to RunBlogRun's news in your inbox. Sign up for our newsletter and we'll keep you informed about the Sport you love.

Subscribe to RunBlogRun's Global News Feed

* indicates required