• Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us
  • Login
  • Register
  • Home
  • Archive
  • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Archive
  • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
No Result
View All Result
Home IAAF

Caster Semenya and the IAAF: Disturbing aspects of the IAAF Lausanne case

Stuart Weirby Stuart Weir
February 27, 2019
0
0 0
0
SHARES
6
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

I recall the win by Caster Semenya in Berlin in 2009. I also recall hearing the horrible booing of Ms. Semenya when she recieved her medal in 2009. Subsequent forensric research suggest the following: 1) Caster herself did not know why she was booed, and her staff, knowing of her issues, did not tell her, b) the IAAF could have dealt with the situation more humanely in 2008 and 2009, c) the situation is now a cause celebre, and has put the IAAF in a position, due only to themselves, as the sexual Grand Inquisitor.

Semenya_CasterA-Zurich18.jpgCaster Semenya, photo by PhotoRun.net

RelatedPosts

This Day in Track & Field History, March 19, 2024, Bill Nieder, Ray Norton, Katherine Switzer and the Avon International Marathon, Leslie Deniz, by Walt Murphy News and Results Service

My excellent adventure, The Payton Jordan (May 4), from the RBR Archives (May 23, 2014)

Coffee with Larry, Some thoughts on Mike Fanelli, competitor, coach, elite manager, husband, friend to many, esteemed track & field historian

The following piece by Stuart Weir, on Caster Semenya, is a departure for Stuart. Both Stuart and I are troubled by this case. The truth is, it should have been managed by the IAAF much better in 2009. At this time, Caster Semenya has become the poster child for the categorization of female athletes. In a time when gender issues are at the forefront, Caster Semenya is a popular concern. (You also might enjoy Stuart’s Ten Questions with Caster Semenya: https://www.runblogrun.com/2018/11/ten-questions-to-caster-semenya-by-stuart-weir.html). Stuart Weir sees all the athletes he interviews a people with human frailties, imperfect souls, who are challenging their limits. Caster Semenya has had many challenges to meet. Consider how you would be with thousands booing you as you get a medal?

I admirer Caster Semenya, she has shown grace and style during this decade long debacle. I have watched her reach out to athletes she has defeated, and her presser with us in London 2017 is a prime example. The situation is of some complication. Rules do need to be made to protect the integrity of women’s athletics, and it has to be managed much better and with more consciousness than the global federation has used in prior efforts. At the end of the day, Caster Semenya has opened the sport to women from South Africa. Also at the end of the day, someone will be hurt by the decision.

Disturbing aspects of the IAAF Lausanne case.

There are a number of things which disturb me deeply about the current Caster Semenya case in Lausanne – and yes, I do think, of despite the IAAF’s protestations about categories of athletes, it is hard not to see the new rules as designed to stop Caster Semenya dominating the middle-distance races.

What I want to say has already been eloquently expressed by Billie Jean King on Twitter: “Forcing women w/naturally high testosterone to give up ownership of their bodies & take drugs to compete in sport is barbaric, dangerous, and discriminatory”. “Barbaric, dangerous, and discriminatory” are strong words but I think they are justified.

Semenya_CasterFH-Pre18.jpgCaster Semenya, photo by PhotoRun.net

The IAAF statement declares that their purpose is to “to ensure fair competition for all women”. In an excellent article in the London Times (20 February) Matthew Syed demonstrates that the concept of “fairness” in sport is misplaced. Syed’s argument includes a reference to Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia’s point that basketball discriminates against short people. In our own sport, a 6 foot 3 woman has a massive advantage over a 5 foot 6 women in the high jump.

To tell someone that they have to change the body they were born with before they can compete is a disturbing situation. The requirement for someone to take medication which is medically unnecessary for their health – and may well be shown in years to come to have side effects is unethical. A practicing doctor in the UK, to whom I spoke, told me she would be professionally unwilling to prescribe such drugs to a patient when there was no medical justification and when there could be damaging side-effects.

I read a quote from Jonathan Taylor, the IAAF’s lawyer, that if the IAAF did not win the case: “DSD and transgender athletes will dominate the podiums and prize money in sport, and women with normal female testosterone levels will not have any chance to win”. Really, then why is there pretty limited evidence of that at the moment? I have watched some magnificently competitive women’s 800 meters races such as Monaco 2017.

I am also reminded of the argument that was used against allowing Markus Rehm, the German amputee long jumper, to compete in IAAF events as opposed to IPC events, that people jumping with blades had an advantage. Rehm reasonably asked, if that were so, why was he the only para-athlete jumping eight meters.

While I’m sure the IAAF, is not racially motivated, it is, as the South African sports minister, Tokozile Xasa has pointed out interesting that the athletes who would be most affected all seem to be black. He said: “These regulations appear to be specifically targeting Caster Semenya. It’s a subtle racial incident we are observing”.

It is a fact of human life that people come in different shapes and sizes and inevitably in some sports some body types will have an advantage. Should we ban female high jumpers who are over 6 foot? After all, it is not “normal” for women to be more than 6 foot. It is extremely rare in Asia. So a logical conclusion, to protect the integrity of the sport, would be to ban these are abnormal woman for being too tall. Long distance races have tended to be dominated by east Africans. Do they have a genetic or other advantage which needs to be investigated? Or should we just ban them for being too fast?

Size and weight are significant contributing factors to the distance athletes can throw a discus or a javelin etc. To protect the fairness of the sport should we not have lightweight, middleweight, welterweight, heavyweight etc categories for throwing events like they do in boxing and wrestling? Or should the distance thrown be related to body weight? This would all be the slippery slope towards an IPC classification system with its 16 different categories of men’s 100 meter races?

The IAAF has set an arbitrary acceptance level of testosterone at five nanomoles per liter on the grounds that levels of testosterone give athletes an advantage. Is the IAAF going to set an acceptable level of testosterone for men too or is the advantage a male with higher levels of testosterone has over a male with lower levels, an acceptable unfairness?

It is an interesting question which unfairnesses the IAAF is happy to accept, and which it is no. But as readers of George Orwell’s Animal Farm know: “All animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than others“.

Caster Semenya is an amazing athlete – I speak as one who has seen all her major races since 2009 – who “has been turned into the freak act at a circus” (Syed). And those of us who have been around for a few years will remember the embarrassingly inept handling of her case by the IAAF in 2009.

I seem myself as loyal to the powers that be in our sport, but, and I am sad to say it. This time I hope the IAAF lose their case.

Author

  • Stuart Weir

    Since 2015, Stuart Weir has written for RunBlogRun. He attends about 20 events a year including all most global championships and Diamond Leagues. He enjoys finding the quirky and obscure story.

    View all posts
Previous Post

2019 HOKA ONE ONE Spring Track & Field Training Week 8, Day 3: Core work, and a run

Next Post

2019 Glasgow Diary: EME News’ Preview of European Athletics Indoors Championships, March 1-3, 2019

Stuart Weir

Stuart Weir

Since 2015, Stuart Weir has written for RunBlogRun. He attends about 20 events a year including all most global championships and Diamond Leagues. He enjoys finding the quirky and obscure story.

Similar Post

European Athletics Euro Cup 10,000m 2025 (27th edition), Pacé, France, courtesy of European Athletics
European Athletics

European Athletics Euro Cup 10,000m 2025 (27th edition), Pacé, France, courtesy of European Athletics

May 25, 2025
LARKIN, PHILIBERT-THIBOUTOT TAKE CANADIAN 10-K TITLES IN OTTAWA
Road Racing

LARKIN, PHILIBERT-THIBOUTOT TAKE CANADIAN 10-K TITLES IN OTTAWA

May 25, 2025
ALBERTSON, LINKLETTER SET TO COMPLETE BOSTON / OTTAWA MARATHON DOUBLE ON SUNDAY
Road Racing

ALBERTSON, LINKLETTER SET TO COMPLETE BOSTON / OTTAWA MARATHON DOUBLE ON SUNDAY

May 25, 2025
2023 Rabat Diamond League: El Bakkali is the best at the end…
Continental Tour Gold

75. Boris Hanžeković Memorial Sports Park Mladost, Zagreb (CRO) – 22-24 May 2025, results compiled by World Athletics Results

May 25, 2025
MERCY ME! CHELANGAT TO MAKE MARATHON DEBUT IN OTTAWA ON SUNDAY
Road Racing

MERCY ME! CHELANGAT TO MAKE MARATHON DEBUT IN OTTAWA ON SUNDAY

May 25, 2025
Laura Muir Headlines Sensational Rudin Women’s Wanamaker Mile at the 115th Millrose Games on Saturday, February 11th
Spring Training

2025 Spring Racing/Training Program, May 24, 2025, week 10, day 6, Tenth Week of the season, a day at the races!

May 25, 2025

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Subscribe to RunBlogRun's Global News Feed

Wake up to RunBlogRun’s news in your inbox. Sign up for our newsletter and we’ll keep you informed about the Sport you love.

*we hate spam as much as you do

  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Clyde Hart’s Guide to 400 meter training (from 1996 Super Clinic Notes/World Coaches Notes)

Clyde Hart’s Guide to 400 meter training (from 1996 Super Clinic Notes/World Coaches Notes)

April 5, 2023
2023 Nike Pre Classic: Two Amazing Days of Track & Field!

Noah Lyles, The Clock Doesn’t Lie

March 7, 2024
USATF / Day Four:  USA’s Assembled Team Is Ready!

Abby Steiner replies via twitter, on the curiosity about her new professional running contract

February 6, 2025
Grand Slam Track’s Kingston Slam Comes to a Close with 12 Slam Champions

2025 Spring Racing/Training Program, April 11, 2025, week 4, day 5, fourth week of year, Friday is an easy day!

April 12, 2025
Mondo Duplantis and the Jump that made him the greatest of all time

Mondo Duplantis and the Jump that made him the greatest of all time

8
What happened to the crowd at Eugene?

What happened to the crowd at Eugene?

7
My Five Biggest Takeaways from the Men’s Olympic Trials Marathon, by Oliver Hinson

My Five Biggest Takeaways from the Men’s Olympic Trials Marathon, by Oliver Hinson

7
Asafa Powell, Considering Longevity in Sprinting

The RunBlogrun Interview: Asafa Powell

5
European Athletics Euro Cup 10,000m 2025 (27th edition), Pacé, France, courtesy of European Athletics

European Athletics Euro Cup 10,000m 2025 (27th edition), Pacé, France, courtesy of European Athletics

May 25, 2025
LARKIN, PHILIBERT-THIBOUTOT TAKE CANADIAN 10-K TITLES IN OTTAWA

LARKIN, PHILIBERT-THIBOUTOT TAKE CANADIAN 10-K TITLES IN OTTAWA

May 25, 2025
ALBERTSON, LINKLETTER SET TO COMPLETE BOSTON / OTTAWA MARATHON DOUBLE ON SUNDAY

ALBERTSON, LINKLETTER SET TO COMPLETE BOSTON / OTTAWA MARATHON DOUBLE ON SUNDAY

May 25, 2025
2023 Rabat Diamond League: El Bakkali is the best at the end…

75. Boris Hanžeković Memorial Sports Park Mladost, Zagreb (CRO) – 22-24 May 2025, results compiled by World Athletics Results

May 25, 2025

Popular Stories

  • Clyde Hart’s Guide to 400 meter training (from 1996 Super Clinic Notes/World Coaches Notes)

    Clyde Hart’s Guide to 400 meter training (from 1996 Super Clinic Notes/World Coaches Notes)

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Noah Lyles, The Clock Doesn’t Lie

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Abby Steiner replies via twitter, on the curiosity about her new professional running contract

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • 2025 Spring Racing/Training Program, April 11, 2025, week 4, day 5, fourth week of year, Friday is an easy day!

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • An epic pole vault competition

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
European Athletics Euro Cup 10,000m 2025 (27th edition), Pacé, France, courtesy of European Athletics
European Athletics

European Athletics Euro Cup 10,000m 2025 (27th edition), Pacé, France, courtesy of European Athletics

May 25, 2025
LARKIN, PHILIBERT-THIBOUTOT TAKE CANADIAN 10-K TITLES IN OTTAWA
Road Racing

LARKIN, PHILIBERT-THIBOUTOT TAKE CANADIAN 10-K TITLES IN OTTAWA

May 25, 2025
ALBERTSON, LINKLETTER SET TO COMPLETE BOSTON / OTTAWA MARATHON DOUBLE ON SUNDAY
Road Racing

ALBERTSON, LINKLETTER SET TO COMPLETE BOSTON / OTTAWA MARATHON DOUBLE ON SUNDAY

May 25, 2025
2023 Rabat Diamond League: El Bakkali is the best at the end…
Continental Tour Gold

75. Boris Hanžeković Memorial Sports Park Mladost, Zagreb (CRO) – 22-24 May 2025, results compiled by World Athletics Results

May 25, 2025

Recent Tweets

Next Post

2019 Glasgow Diary: EME News' Preview of European Athletics Indoors Championships, March 1-3, 2019

runblogrun

RunBlogRun comments on the global world of athletics, sports & ethics, and the Olympic movement. @runblogrun

Browse by Category

Newsletter

Subscribe to our mailing list to receives daily updates direct to your inbox!

  • Home
  • Archive
  • Contact Us

© 2022 Run Blog Run - All Rights Reserved

No Result
View All Result
  • Archive
  • Contact Us
  • Home page
  • My Account
  • Sample Page

© 2022 Run Blog Run - All Rights Reserved

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

Select a password for yourself. (minimum length of 8)

Paste here the user biography.

Provide here the twitter screen name. i.e. @RunBlogRun

Provide here the instagram screen name. i.e. @RunBlogRun

Provide here the facebook profile URL. i.e. http://www.facebook.com/RunBlogRun

Provide here the linkedin profile URL. i.e. https://www.linkedin.com/in/larry-eder-5497253

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

No Result
View All Result
  • Archive
  • Contact Us
  • Home page
  • My Account
  • Sample Page

© 2022 Run Blog Run - All Rights Reserved