• Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us
  • Login
  • Home
  • Archive
  • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Archive
  • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
No Result
View All Result
Home Track & Field

The IAAF Responds to Letter from IWG, WSI and IAPESGW

RBR AdminbyRBR Admin
June 4, 2019
0
0 0
0
SHARES
0
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

The DSD crisis continues, as the IAAF responds to Letter from three prominent groups supporting Women’s sports rights. The full letter is below. This battle over DSD regulations will continue for some time to come.

Semenya_CasterFL1-Zurich18.jpgCaster Semenya, photo by PhotoRun.net

RelatedPosts

CENTENNIAL OLYMPIC PARK TO HOST ADIDAS ATLANTA CITY GAMES on May 6

World Athletics Continental Tour expands for 2023

Miltiadis Tentoglou to battle a tough LJ field in Madrid Indoor on February 22!

iaaf.png

Today the IAAF responded to a letter received last week from Raswyn Lovett, Co-Chair of the International Working Group on Women in Sport (IWG), Diane Huffman, President of WomenSport International (WSI), and Professor Rosa Lopez de D’Amico, President of the International Association of Physical Education for Girls and Women (IAPESGW).

Dear Ms Lovett, Ms Huffman and Professor Lopez de D’Amico,

Thank you for your letter dated 30 May 2019 in relation to the IAAF‘s Eligibility Regulations for the Female Classification (Athletes with Differences of Sex Development) (DSD Regulations).

The IAAF agrees that this is a ‘complex issue’. However, with respect, the IAAF cannot agree with a number of the misconceptions asserted in your letter, notably that the DSD Regulations ‘enforce gender inequality’.

The DSD Regulations were introduced precisely because the IAAF is committed to protecting the rights and opportunities of female athletes. The IAAF is entitled, indeed required, to give male and female athletes an equal chance to excel in elite-level athletics, for the benefit of the athletes themselves, the sport and wider society. It is because of the substantial physical advantages between adult males and females that the female category is protected in sport. Without separate competition categories, female athletes would win no medals or other prizes (and would not even come close to winning). The reason is biological: men have XY chromosomes that lead to testes that produce high levels of testosterone (the hormone that builds larger and stronger bodies with more muscle mass, stronger bones and more haemoglobin in the blood). It is not fair and meaningful for biological women (with XX chromosomes that lead to ovaries that produce much lower levels of testosterone) to compete against men.

The challenge that the IAAF faces is how to accommodate individuals who identify as female (and are legally recognised as female) but who – because of a difference of sex development – have XY chromosomes that lead to testes that produce high levels of testosterone, and therefore have all the same physical advantages over women for the purposes of athletics as men have over women.

All of the concerns that you express in your letter were argued by those appealing the regulations before the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS). The CAS Panel – chaired by an experienced female judge – found that the DSD Regulations were discriminatory but that such discrimination was lawful because the DSD Regulations were a necessary, reasonable and proportionate means of achieving a legitimate objective. That legitimate objective was fair and meaningful competition in the female category of elite athletics.

However, the IAAF wishes to directly address a number of the concerns you have raised in order to avoid the repetition of statements that are misconceived or plainly incorrect:

– The IAAF is not a public authority exercising state powers, but rather a private body exercising private (contractual) powers. Therefore, it is not subject to human rights instruments such as the Universal Declaration of Human Rights or the European Convention on Human Rights. Consistent with that, the IAAF notes that Principle 1(a) of the Brighton plus Helsinki Declaration on Women and Sport that you cite in your letter places obligations on ‘state and government’, not on international sports federations like the IAAF.

– However, the IAAF has itself committed (in Article 4 of the IAAF Constitution) to equal treatment and non-discrimination in athletics. In fact, it is that commitment to equal treatment that mandates provision of a female-only competition category, on the basis that the biological differences between the sexes mean this is the only way to guarantee female athletes an equal chance to excel and to secure the social and other goods that elite sport can offer. Anti-discrimination laws in Australia, the US and the UK recognise the need for this positive discrimination in favour of biological females on the basis of biological sex traits, and so expressly permit this female ‘set-aside’ in sport, and do not allow those excluded from the category to argue this is unlawful.

– The IAAF agrees that the affected DSD athletes have not cheated or doped but strongly disagrees that the DSD Regulation ‘implies wrongdoing and comes with a penalty’. The DSD Regulations themselves state that they ‘exist solely to ensure fair and meaningful competition within the female classification’, and the dignity and privacy of affected athletes will be protected.

– Under no circumstances will the DSD Regulations ‘force an athlete to take medication that alters their natural state’. Athlete consent is built into the DSD Regulations at every stage, and any diagnosis and/or treatment (in either case, if desired by the athlete) is undertaken by world-leading medical experts, independent of the IAAF. It is important to recognise that for many 46 XY individuals with one of the covered DSDs and a female gender identity, such treatment is the recognised standard of care and the medication helps to change their body to better reflect their chosen gender.

– The DSD Regulations are supported by a strong team of world-renowned experts, robust scientific evidence and extensive evidence from elite athletics (please see the Explanatory Notes to the DSD Regulations here: https://www.iaaf.org/news/press-release/questions-answers-iaaf-female-eligibility-reg and research from world renowned experts here: https://www.iaaf.org/news/press-release/cas-dsd-experts (both are available on the IAAFwebsite). The drafting of the DSD Regulations, including the processes and treatment available to affected athletes under them, were informed by consultation with a number of world leading experts in relevant scientific and legal disciplines.

The right to participate in sport does not translate to a right to self-identify into a competition category or an event, or to insist on inclusion in a preferred event, or to win in a particular event, without regard to the legitimate rules of the sport or the criteria for entry. It is legitimate for all sport in general, and for the IAAF in particular, to create a protected category for females and to base eligibility for this category on biology not identity. Any other definition would be category defeating and would deter girls the world over from choosing competitive and elite sport after puberty.

The IAAF is committed to the full participation of women in the sport of athletics, be that as elite female athletes in fair and meaningful competition, as young girls developing life skills, or as administrators or officials. Regrettably, it was not so long ago that women were not permitted to compete in sport at all. There is a lot of work to be done, but the IAAF is at the forefront of that work. Indeed, the IAAF is one of the only international sports federations to pay women and men equal prize money. It is one of the IAAF‘s core values to promote and achieve equal treatment and opportunity for women and girls in athletics. I look forward to working with you to achieve that goal.

IAAF

Author

  • RBR Admin
    RBR Admin

    View all posts

Previous Post

2019 Rome DL Diary: The highlight of the meet will be the men’s 200 meters!

Next Post

2019 HOKA ONE ONE Spring Track & Field Training Week 22, Day 3: Championship weeks/ and Recovery Weeks

RBR Admin

RBR Admin

Similar Post

Cofffee With Larry, Sirikwa Classic World Cross Country, NB Indoor Grand Prix, Millrose Games, Dubai Marathon, USATF Indoors
News

Cofffee With Larry, Sirikwa Classic World Cross Country, NB Indoor Grand Prix, Millrose Games, Dubai Marathon, USATF Indoors

January 30, 2023
2023 RunBlogRun Winter Training Block, Week 4, Day 7, Sunday is a long run…
Winter Training

2023 RunBlogRun Winter Training Block, Week 4, Day 7, Sunday is a long run…

January 30, 2023
Yared Nuguse sets AR for 3,000m in 7:28.24 at Boston Terrier Classic (updated with event photos)
American Records

Yared Nuguse sets AR for 3,000m in 7:28.24 at Boston Terrier Classic (updated with event photos)

January 29, 2023
The Sirikwa Classic World Cross Country Tour is expected to be bigger this year
African Athletics

The Sirikwa Classic World Cross Country Tour is expected to be bigger this year

January 30, 2023
Woody Kincaid sets AR for 5,000m, 12:51.61,  in titanic struggle with Joe Klecker, 12:54.99, both under 13 minutes!
American Records

Woody Kincaid sets AR for 5,000m, 12:51.61, in titanic struggle with Joe Klecker, 12:54.99, both under 13 minutes!

January 29, 2023
Coffee With Larry: Yared Nuguse’s AR 3,000m in 7:28.24, Woody Kincaid’s 12:51.61, 5000m AR, HOT Karlsruhe Meeting, Keely Hodgkinson runs fast 600 meters, sets meet record!
News

Coffee With Larry: Yared Nuguse’s AR 3,000m in 7:28.24, Woody Kincaid’s 12:51.61, 5000m AR, HOT Karlsruhe Meeting, Keely Hodgkinson runs fast 600 meters, sets meet record!

January 28, 2023

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Subscribe to RunBlogRun's Global News Feed

Wake up to RunBlogRun’s news in your inbox. Sign up for our newsletter and we’ll keep you informed about the Sport you love.

*we hate spam as much as you do

  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
USATF / Day Four:  USA’s Assembled Team Is Ready!

Abby Steiner replies via twitter, on the curiosity about her new professional running contract

July 5, 2022
What happened to the crowd at Eugene?

What happened to the crowd at Eugene?

July 17, 2022
Oregon 22 World Athletics Champs: False Starts reconsidered

Oregon 22 World Athletics Champs: False Starts reconsidered

November 18, 2022
Wanda Diamond League Final plans, 2023-2027, from World Athletics Website

Wanda Diamond League Final plans, 2023-2027, from World Athletics Website

October 14, 2022
Asafa Powell, Considering Longevity in Sprinting

The RunBlogrun Interview: Asafa Powell

5
What happened to the crowd at Eugene?

What happened to the crowd at Eugene?

5
TCS New York City Marathon Broadcast to be Available in More Than 530 Million Homes Around the World on Sunday, November 6

RunblogRun Editorial: The Sorry State of Running Television Coverage, by Peter Abraham, note by Larry Eder

4
Cary Pinkowski did the Heroic Thing–My letter to CNN on the LSB Chicago Marathon

Cary Pinkowski did the Heroic Thing–My letter to CNN on the LSB Chicago Marathon

3
Cofffee With Larry, Sirikwa Classic World Cross Country, NB Indoor Grand Prix, Millrose Games, Dubai Marathon, USATF Indoors

Cofffee With Larry, Sirikwa Classic World Cross Country, NB Indoor Grand Prix, Millrose Games, Dubai Marathon, USATF Indoors

January 30, 2023
2023 RunBlogRun Winter Training Block, Week 4, Day 7, Sunday is a long run…

2023 RunBlogRun Winter Training Block, Week 4, Day 7, Sunday is a long run…

January 30, 2023
Yared Nuguse sets AR for 3,000m in 7:28.24 at Boston Terrier Classic (updated with event photos)

Yared Nuguse sets AR for 3,000m in 7:28.24 at Boston Terrier Classic (updated with event photos)

January 29, 2023
The Sirikwa Classic World Cross Country Tour is expected to be bigger this year

The Sirikwa Classic World Cross Country Tour is expected to be bigger this year

January 30, 2023

Popular Stories

  • USATF / Day Four:  USA’s Assembled Team Is Ready!

    Abby Steiner replies via twitter, on the curiosity about her new professional running contract

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • What happened to the crowd at Eugene?

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Oregon 22 World Athletics Champs: False Starts reconsidered

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Wanda Diamond League Final plans, 2023-2027, from World Athletics Website

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Howard Slusher, RIP, 1937-2022, the man behind the new Hayward Field

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0

Recent Tweets

RunBlogRun Follow

RunBlogRun comments on the global world of athletics, sports & ethics, and the Olympic movement. RunBlogRun is the voice of the sport.

RunBlogRun
runblogrun RunBlogRun @runblogrun ·
12h

High school athletes and coaches, do not miss the http://www.nbnationals.com, March 10-12, 2023, #nbnationals, #newbalance, #americantrackandfield,

Reply on Twitter 1619937216876412930 Retweet on Twitter 1619937216876412930 1 Like on Twitter 1619937216876412930 Twitter 1619937216876412930
runblogrun RunBlogRun @runblogrun ·
13h

Athanas Kioko, 2023 Boston Terrier Classic, January 27, 2023, photo by #KevinMorris, #BostonTerrierClassic, #tracklife, #trackandlife, #usatf, #WAIndoorTour, #bostoncollege,

Reply on Twitter 1619928050669441024 Retweet on Twitter 1619928050669441024 Like on Twitter 1619928050669441024 Twitter 1619928050669441024
runblogrun RunBlogRun @runblogrun ·
13h

Woody Kincaid sets AR at 5000m in 12:51.61, 2023 Boston Terrier Classic, January 27, 2023, photo by #KevinMorris, #BostonTerrierClassic, #tracklife, #trackandlife, #usatf, #WAIndoorTour, ...@nikeathletics, #woodykincaid, #bostoncollege,

Reply on Twitter 1619927187402162180 Retweet on Twitter 1619927187402162180 Like on Twitter 1619927187402162180 1 Twitter 1619927187402162180
runblogrun RunBlogRun @runblogrun ·
13h

Woody Kincaid sets AR at 5000m in 12:51.61, 2023 Boston Terrier Classic, January 27, 2023, photo by #KevinMorris, #BostonTerrierClassic, #tracklife, #trackandlife, #usatf, #WAIndoorTour, ...@nikeathletics, #woodykincaid, #bostoncollege,

Reply on Twitter 1619926967616442369 Retweet on Twitter 1619926967616442369 1 Like on Twitter 1619926967616442369 1 Twitter 1619926967616442369
runblogrun RunBlogRun @runblogrun ·
13h

Hobbs Kessler, 2023 Boston Terrier Classic, January 27, 2023, photo by #KevinMorris, #BostonTerrierClassic, #tracklife, #trackandlife, #usatf, #WAIndoorTour, @adidasrunning, #verynicetrackclub, ...#ronwarhurst,

Reply on Twitter 1619923327266734080 Retweet on Twitter 1619923327266734080 Like on Twitter 1619923327266734080 3 Twitter 1619923327266734080
Load More...
Next Post

2019 HOKA ONE ONE Spring Track & Field Training Week 22, Day 3: Championship weeks/ and Recovery Weeks

runblogrun

RunBlogRun comments on the global world of athletics, sports & ethics, and the Olympic movement. @runblogrun

Browse by Category

Newsletter

Subscribe to our mailing list to receives daily updates direct to your inbox!

  • Home
  • Archive
  • Contact Us

© 2022 Run Blog Run - All Rights Reserved

No Result
View All Result
  • Archive
  • Contact Us
  • Home page
  • My Account
  • Sample Page

© 2022 Run Blog Run - All Rights Reserved

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist