• Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us
  • Login
  • Register
  • Home
  • Archive
  • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Archive
  • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
No Result
View All Result
Home doping and sports

The Problems with the Proposal to Expunge all World records, by Stuart Weir

Stuart Weirby Stuart Weir
May 4, 2017
0
0 0
0
SHARES
5
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

The award for the biggest PR disaster of the past few weeks was the proposal to bring credibility to athletics regarding some of its world records. The important word is “some”. Most of those records were known to anyone who spent a bit of time checking out World Records. There have been times in our sport when anti doping was the focus of dilettantes. It was an after thought. This is not so anymore.

The recent proposal wants to put a line in the sand, and look to the future. It was an approach to a complicated problem in our sport. This approach may not be the right way to go. In this article, Stuart Weir is definitely not a fan, and he says why.

RelatedPosts

Marcell Jacobs will be ready!

Femke Bol and Jessica Schilder eagerly anticipating Hengelo: Both in top form for the 44th edition of the FBK Games

European Athletics Euro Cup 10,000m 2025 (27th edition), Pacé, France, courtesy of European Athletics

Radcliffe_Paula1a-Vienna12.jpgPaul Radcliffe, photo by PhotoRun.net

We are in a time when changes need to be made. But, as Stuart Weir notes, this proposal, while well meaning, has had the absolute result of bringing most of the sport’s frustration down on those involved.

A good idea to change our record system, but this does not seem to be the way.

The proposal to expunge all world records set prior to 2005 is flawed! There is an argument that a grand gesture is needed to demonstrate that there is a will to clean up the sport. There has been the inevitable outcry from athletes who will lose their world records. Interestingly at the Doha Diamond League press conferences, athletes seemed quite divided on the idea. The proposal is flawed because 2005 is an arbitrary date. So all world records set after 2005 are squeaky clean then? It also begs the question as to whether 2017 World records will be cancelled in 2030 because 2017 testing protocols will seem embarrassingly prehistoric by 2030.

But the real reason the proposal is flawed is that it is based on presumption of guilt rather than actual evidence. The consensus of opinion within the sport is that some old world records are suspicious and that others are solid and credible. To expunge all on grounds of age – rather than evidence – is inherently unsatisfactory. It also goes against the traditional legal principle of the presumption of innocence until proved guilty.

But I wonder if there is a bigger issue and if the process is actually flawed by the very desire to compare past and present. We love to do it. Would Joe Louis have beaten Muhammed Ali? How would Rod Laver fare against Bjorn Borg or Novak Djokovic? Jack Nicklaus or Tiger Woods each in their heyday? We could go on posing these fascinating yet unanswerable questions all day.

It is a principle of sport that you can only beat those who turn up to compete on the day. Brianna Rollins is the current Olympic champion in the 100H. Is her achievement lessened by the fact that world record holder Kendra Harrison was not in the final? Not in my book, Brianna took on everyone who lined up in the final that day in Rio and beat them.

It is not as if all records are equal any way. Surely a record run in a competitive championship race is worth far more than a manufactured, paced, “exhibition” race.

There is no doubting that there is a problem but none of the proposed solutions seems satisfactory. Would it perhaps be better to give less attention to world records and concentrate on the current year. We could award prizes for the fastest, highest and longest in 2017, then start again on 1 January 2018. That way we would be likely to be comparing like with like.

Author

  • Stuart Weir

    Since 2015, Stuart Weir has written for RunBlogRun. He attends about 20 events a year including all most global championships and Diamond Leagues. He enjoys finding the quirky and obscure story.

    View all posts
Previous Post

2017 Doha DL Diaries: Event by Event Preview, from EME News

Next Post

PUMA’s Jose Van der Veen explains PUMA NETFIT!

Stuart Weir

Stuart Weir

Since 2015, Stuart Weir has written for RunBlogRun. He attends about 20 events a year including all most global championships and Diamond Leagues. He enjoys finding the quirky and obscure story.

Similar Post

Night of the British PRs – and a National record.
Uncategorized

Night of the British PRs – and a National record.

June 13, 2025
All Diamond Leagues are equal but some are more equal than others
Diamond League

All Diamond Leagues are equal but some are more equal than others

June 13, 2025
Six take-aways from the Golden Gala (Golden Gala Roma 2025)
Coffee With Larry

Coffee with Larry, June 11, 2025, Some thoughts on Rome, Oslo Diamond League

June 13, 2025
This Day in Track & Field, June 12, Walter Tewksbury was first American to break 11 seconds (1900), Kjell Isaksson sets PV WR (1972), written by Walt Murphy
Athletic History

This Day in Track & Field, June 12, Walter Tewksbury was first American to break 11 seconds (1900), Kjell Isaksson sets PV WR (1972), written by Walt Murphy

June 13, 2025
Viva Italia (Golden Gala Roma, June 6, 2025)
Spring Training

2025 Spring Racing/Training Program, June 12, 2025, week 13, day 4, Second week of sharpening, Second week, transition from track to cross country.

June 13, 2025
Coffee with Larry, Bauhaus Stockholm was a rainy success, but what about the protesters?
Diamond League

300m hurdles clash, 5000m WR attempt, Alfred’s 100m debut, and … Mondo (Preview of Oslo Diamond League)

June 12, 2025

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Subscribe to RunBlogRun's Global News Feed

Wake up to RunBlogRun’s news in your inbox. Sign up for our newsletter and we’ll keep you informed about the Sport you love.

*we hate spam as much as you do

  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Clyde Hart’s Guide to 400 meter training (from 1996 Super Clinic Notes/World Coaches Notes)

Clyde Hart’s Guide to 400 meter training (from 1996 Super Clinic Notes/World Coaches Notes)

April 5, 2023
2023 Nike Pre Classic: Two Amazing Days of Track & Field!

Noah Lyles, The Clock Doesn’t Lie

March 7, 2024
USATF / Day Four:  USA’s Assembled Team Is Ready!

Abby Steiner replies via twitter, on the curiosity about her new professional running contract

February 6, 2025
Grand Slam Track’s Kingston Slam Comes to a Close with 12 Slam Champions

2025 Spring Racing/Training Program, April 11, 2025, week 4, day 5, fourth week of year, Friday is an easy day!

April 12, 2025
Mondo Duplantis and the Jump that made him the greatest of all time

Mondo Duplantis and the Jump that made him the greatest of all time

8
What happened to the crowd at Eugene?

What happened to the crowd at Eugene?

7
My Five Biggest Takeaways from the Men’s Olympic Trials Marathon, by Oliver Hinson

My Five Biggest Takeaways from the Men’s Olympic Trials Marathon, by Oliver Hinson

7
Asafa Powell, Considering Longevity in Sprinting

The RunBlogrun Interview: Asafa Powell

5
Night of the British PRs – and a National record.

Night of the British PRs – and a National record.

June 13, 2025
All Diamond Leagues are equal but some are more equal than others

All Diamond Leagues are equal but some are more equal than others

June 13, 2025
Six take-aways from the Golden Gala (Golden Gala Roma 2025)

Coffee with Larry, June 11, 2025, Some thoughts on Rome, Oslo Diamond League

June 13, 2025
This Day in Track & Field, June 12, Walter Tewksbury was first American to break 11 seconds (1900), Kjell Isaksson sets PV WR (1972), written by Walt Murphy

This Day in Track & Field, June 12, Walter Tewksbury was first American to break 11 seconds (1900), Kjell Isaksson sets PV WR (1972), written by Walt Murphy

June 13, 2025

Popular Stories

  • Clyde Hart’s Guide to 400 meter training (from 1996 Super Clinic Notes/World Coaches Notes)

    Clyde Hart’s Guide to 400 meter training (from 1996 Super Clinic Notes/World Coaches Notes)

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Noah Lyles, The Clock Doesn’t Lie

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Abby Steiner replies via twitter, on the curiosity about her new professional running contract

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • 2025 Spring Racing/Training Program, April 11, 2025, week 4, day 5, fourth week of year, Friday is an easy day!

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • An epic pole vault competition

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
Night of the British PRs – and a National record.
Uncategorized

Night of the British PRs – and a National record.

June 13, 2025
All Diamond Leagues are equal but some are more equal than others
Diamond League

All Diamond Leagues are equal but some are more equal than others

June 13, 2025
Six take-aways from the Golden Gala (Golden Gala Roma 2025)
Coffee With Larry

Coffee with Larry, June 11, 2025, Some thoughts on Rome, Oslo Diamond League

June 13, 2025
This Day in Track & Field, June 12, Walter Tewksbury was first American to break 11 seconds (1900), Kjell Isaksson sets PV WR (1972), written by Walt Murphy
Athletic History

This Day in Track & Field, June 12, Walter Tewksbury was first American to break 11 seconds (1900), Kjell Isaksson sets PV WR (1972), written by Walt Murphy

June 13, 2025

Recent Tweets

Next Post

PUMA's Jose Van der Veen explains PUMA NETFIT!

runblogrun

RunBlogRun comments on the global world of athletics, sports & ethics, and the Olympic movement. @runblogrun

Browse by Category

Newsletter

Subscribe to our mailing list to receives daily updates direct to your inbox!

  • Home
  • Archive
  • Contact Us

© 2022 Run Blog Run - All Rights Reserved

No Result
View All Result
  • Archive
  • Contact Us
  • Home page
  • My Account
  • Sample Page

© 2022 Run Blog Run - All Rights Reserved

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

Select a password for yourself. (minimum length of 8)

Paste here the user biography.

Provide here the twitter screen name. i.e. @RunBlogRun

Provide here the instagram screen name. i.e. @RunBlogRun

Provide here the facebook profile URL. i.e. http://www.facebook.com/RunBlogRun

Provide here the linkedin profile URL. i.e. https://www.linkedin.com/in/larry-eder-5497253

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

No Result
View All Result
  • Archive
  • Contact Us
  • Home page
  • My Account
  • Sample Page

© 2022 Run Blog Run - All Rights Reserved