• Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us
  • Login
  • Register
  • Home
  • Archive
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Archive
No Result
View All Result
No Result
View All Result
Home Sports & Marketing

From Lane One: A Case For an Update to the World Athletics Ranking System, #4, By Matt Wisner

RBR AdminbyRBR Admin
October 18, 2021
0
From Lane One: A Case For an Update to the World Athletics Ranking System, #4, By Matt Wisner
0 0
0
SHARES
5
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

This is Matt Wisner’s 4th column. He has some concerns with the new World Athletics rankings. Several people have addressed their concerns about how to fine tune WA rankings to make it better.

McLaughlin_Sydney-Q1a-OlyTrials21w.jpgSydney McLauglin, does she need to race more to place higher in WA ranking system? photo by Kevin Morris / @kevmofoto

RelatedPosts

Atlanta Track Club Announces Long-Term Partnership with adidas! adidas to be Club’s Footwear and Apparel Partner Starting in 2022

Does the Olympics Media Market the Wrong Stars? by Orrin Konheim

Agents at Annual Meeting

A Case For an Update to the World Athletics Ranking System

By Matt Wisner

On September 28, World Athletics released the final iteration of their “overall rankings,” a list that ranks all track and field athletes and proposes standardization across events. The lists have glaring errors.

The idea is that the most impressive athletes this year should be at the top of the list. The scoring system clearly takes into account multiple performances, meaning that if an athlete has a bad day, that won’t wreck their chances at ranking well.

The scoring system also necessitates multiple impressive performances; it takes the average of an athlete’s five best scores. Sydney McLaughlin’s final ranking, for example, was vulnerable to this design flaw. She only competed three times in her main event, the 400-meter hurdles: once in Nashville, then the U.S. Olympic Trials, and then the Olympic Games.

McLaughlin was the Olympic champion in Tokyo. She set the World Record in the event. And she won every time she stepped on the line. She did not make the top-10 on the World Athletics list.

Femke Bol, the bronze medalist from Tokyo in the same event, did make the list. According to World Athletics, Femke Bol was the sixth most impressive woman in track and field this year. Bol was clearly rewarded for competing in the 400 hurdles in eight distinct meets, five of which were Diamond League meets, and one of which was the Olympics. To her credit, Bol has had arguably the most impressive progression in her event over the past year, and she won her 400 hurdles races every time she stepped on the track–except for when McLaughlin was also in the field.

The requirement of multiple strong performances also disadvantages distance runners, who may need a longer recovery period than a sprinter or jumper or thrower between competitions. Sifan Hassan is extraordinary, and still ended up second on the list despite this barrier, but Jakob Ingebrigtsen placing eighth on the men’s list may be a better example. Ingebrigtsen is the only male distance runner in the top-10, while five are sprinters or hurdlers.

The metric also favors Diamond League performances, which makes it eurocentric; it’s no secret that European athletes are accepted into Diamond League meets more than athletes from other continents. Ten of the 12 Diamond League meetings take place in Europe (there’s one in Eugene and one in Doha). The meet organizers are mostly European. Etc. Perhaps the problem isn’t that the overall rankings metric is eurocentric, but the Diamond League meet schedule is. Either way, there’s a problem.

The Diamond League and World Athletics are not the same thing. They’re separate organizations. World Athletics proposes to be an impartial international governing body for track and field, but it’s certainly tangled up with the Diamond League, explicitly or not. The world rank system which qualifies athletes without the Olympic standard to the Olympics, for example, prioritizes competition at Diamond League meets; they’re virtually the only “A” class meets available.

Maybe the World Athletics overall ranking is another attempt to encourage elite athletes to participate in Diamond League meets.

Another omission from the women’s overall ranking top-10 is Athing Mu, the Olympic gold medalist in the 800. Mu raced 36 times in 2021. She won 35. Mu was a collegiate athlete for most of the season, and NCAA meets are not rewarded well under the World Athletics scoring system. But outside of her three NCAA titles, Mu won the Pre Classic 800, the U.S. Olympic Trials 800, and the 800 in Tokyo. She is the eighth fastest woman in history in the event. She is not in the World Athletics top 10 this year.

The men’s list also has obvious errors. Alison Dos Santos, the bronze medalist in the 400 hurdles from Tokyo, made the top-10 (eighth) while Rai Benjamin did not. Benjamin earned the silver medal in the event and is the second fastest performer ever. This is the same situation as McLaughlin and Bol; Dos Santos was prolific on the Diamond League circuit while Benjamin mostly competed in the U.S.

David Melly deserves a shoutout for beating me to this analysis. He tweeted his critique a few days ago. We share the opinion that the scoring system is in need of an update.

A good scoring system balances fast times with impressive placement over strong competition. The current World Athletics scoring system sometimes does that, but there are clear blindspots.

Author

  • RBR Admin

    View all posts

Previous Post

2021 RunBlogRun, week # 5, Fall Cross Country Racing Season, Day 1

Next Post

This year’s finest athletics achievements will be celebrated at the World Athletics Awards 2021.

RBR Admin

RBR Admin

Similar Post

2022 Bauhaus Stockholm Diamond League: an overview
2022 Wanda Diamond League

2022 Bauhaus Stockholm Diamond League: an overview

July 1, 2022
2022 Bauhaus Stockholm DL: Mondo Duplantis clears 6.16m! WL/MR/NR
2022 Wanda Diamond League

2022 Bauhaus Stockholm DL: Mondo Duplantis clears 6.16m! WL/MR/NR

June 30, 2022
Where does Nike running go from here?  (from the Archives, May 10, 2010, with updates)
Media

Where does Nike running go from here? (from the Archives, May 10, 2010, with updates)

July 1, 2022
USATF / Day Three: Glorious Performances: McLaughlin’s 51.41 WR Highlights Amazing Day 
Track & Field

2022 RunBlogRun, Recovery Week 3, Day 3 (June 29, 2022)

June 30, 2022
2022 USATF Outdoor Champs: Sandi Morris takes the Women’s Pole Vault in style!
Events

2022 USATF Outdoor Champs: Sandi Morris takes the Women’s Pole Vault in style!

June 29, 2022
2022 USATF Outdoor Champs: Cooper Teare wins the Men’s 1,500 meters!
Events

2022 USATF Outdoor Champs: Cooper Teare wins the Men’s 1,500 meters!

June 29, 2022

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subscribe to RunBlogRun's Global News Feed

Wake up to RunBlogRun’s news in your inbox. Sign up for our newsletter and we’ll keep you informed about the Sport you love.

*we hate spam as much as you do

Recent Stories

Track & Field

Zuzana Hejnova to compete in Doha DL over 400m hurdles, from EME News (source:IAAF)

by Alfonz Juck
April 4, 2022
0

Zuzana Hejnova, photo by PhotoRun.net Hejnova opens in DohaDOHA (QAT): World 200m champion Dafne Schippers will go head-to-head with world...

Zuzana Hejnova runs 38.16 All time best for 300m hurdles, by Alfons Juck, note by Larry Eder

April 4, 2022

Zurich’s Grand Venue: Letzigrund Stadium Inspires Exceptional Performances

April 4, 2022

Zurich Weltklasse, the Olympics in One Night, by Bob Ramsak, Notes by Larry Eder

June 23, 2022

Recent Tweets

RunBlogRun Follow

RunBlogRun comments on the global world of athletics, sports & ethics, and the Olympic movement. RunBlogRun is the voice of the sport.

RunBlogRun
runblogrun RunBlogRun @runblogrun ·
7h

Where does Nike running go from here? by Larry Eder https://bit.ly/3OWYFqL , #nikerunning, photo by Jeff Johnson/curated by Walt Chadwick, #trackandfieldlife, #runningshoes, #shoetech, #haywardfield,... #usatf, #worldathletics, #runnersworld, #runningmagazine, @Running_Network,

Reply on Twitter 1542673865566035968 Retweet on Twitter 1542673865566035968 Like on Twitter 1542673865566035968 1 Twitter 1542673865566035968
Retweet on Twitter RunBlogRun Retweeted
shaolinsplit ShaolinSplit @shaolinsplit ·
8h

Keely Hodgkinson UPSET by Mary Moraa in Diamond League stunner | NBC Sports https://youtu.be/Qf75RRQ1TTA

Reply on Twitter 1542664297226313728 Retweet on Twitter 1542664297226313728 1 Like on Twitter 1542664297226313728 2 Twitter 1542664297226313728
Retweet on Twitter RunBlogRun Retweeted
scuxctf Santa Clara Cross Country/Track & Field @scuxctf ·
8h

Check out our Broncos on the @WCCsports All-Academic teams!

➡️ http://spr.ly/6017zlRrL

#StampedeTogether

Reply on Twitter 1542666801015816193 Retweet on Twitter 1542666801015816193 1 Like on Twitter 1542666801015816193 2 Twitter 1542666801015816193
runblogrun RunBlogRun @runblogrun ·
7h

Where does Nike running go from here? by Larry Eder https://www.runblogrun.com/?p=2920 , #nikerunning, photo by Jeff Johnson/curated by Walt Chadwick, #trackandfieldlife, #runningshoes, #shoetech, ...#haywardfield, #usatf, #worldathletics, #runnersworld, #runningmagazine, @Running_Network,

Reply on Twitter 1542673547369365505 Retweet on Twitter 1542673547369365505 Like on Twitter 1542673547369365505 Twitter 1542673547369365505
runblogrun RunBlogRun @runblogrun ·
8h

Jasmine Camacho-Quinn is focused on @WCHoregon22, @bauhausgalan, #stockholmDL,

Victor K Almeida 📰 @AlmeidaVictorK

Olympic champion, Jasmine Camacho-Quinn 🇵🇷 claims the victory in 100mH with a leading time of 12.46s

2. Tobi Amusam 🇳🇬 (12.50s)
3. Nia Ali 🇺🇸 (12.53s)

Reply on Twitter 1542658031510585345 Retweet on Twitter 1542658031510585345 Like on Twitter 1542658031510585345 Twitter 1542658031510585345
Load More...
Next Post

This year's finest athletics achievements will be celebrated at the World Athletics Awards 2021.

runblogrun

RunBlogRun comments on the global world of athletics, sports & ethics, and the Olympic movement. @runblogrun

Browse by Category

Newsletter

Subscribe to our mailing list to receives daily updates direct to your inbox!

  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy & Policy
  • Contact Us

© 2022 Run Blog Run - All Rights Reserved

No Result
View All Result
  • Archive
  • Contact Us
  • Home page
  • My Account

© 2022 Run Blog Run - All Rights Reserved

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

Select a password for yourself. (minimum length of 8)

Paste here the user biography.

Provide here the twitter screen name. i.e. @RunBlogRun

Provide here the instagram screen name. i.e. @RunBlogRun

Provide here the facebook profile URL. i.e. http://www.facebook.com/RunBlogRun

Provide here the linkedin profile URL. i.e. https://www.linkedin.com/in/larry-eder-5497253

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist